Legal and environmental prerequisites for classifying large HPPs as renewable energy sources in Tajikistan: initiating the discussion

Sultonova T.I.*, Ulugov U.A.

---

^{Russian-Tajik (Slavonic) University. 734025, Republic of Tajikistan, Dushanbe, st. M. Tursunzade, 30.}

Email: t.sultonova77@gmail.com

https://doi.org/10.29258/CAJSCR/2022/27-44.rus

October 24, 2022

Abstract

The article aims to trigger the discussion on one of the most pressing issues of modern power-related legislation extremely important for the further development of the power sector of the Republic of Tajikistan and other states possessing significant hydropower potential. In particular, the article raises the problem of the unsoundness of the generally recognized perception of large-scale hydroelectric power plants (HPPs) as not belonging to renewable sources of energy. The authors examined a series of publications setting out the idea of recognizing HPPs as renewables and elaborated it based on own observations and arguments in the context of Tajikistan’s hydropower capacity. The research investigated the theoretical conclusions, regulatory provisions of national legislations and international legal documents describing the legal essence of the concepts of “renewable” and “traditional” energies. The study aimed to legally and technically justify large HPPs bearing all the characteristics of renewable energy generation based on the available findings of technical, environmental, and legal studies, as well as empirical data, own expertise, and other information. The study’s methodological basis included a set of general scientific cognition (dialectical, analytical, and synthetic) and purely scientific research (formal-legal, comparative-legal, and technical-legal) methods. The authors conclude that in the normative and conceptual apparatus of energy legislation, the concepts of “renewable” and “traditional” energies are interpreted via their juxtaposition, which is incorrect; and suggest the idea that traditional and renewable energies are not mutually exclusive, but quite compatible concepts. All renewable power may well claim to be traditional, and — like traditional energy — may be based on utilizing renewable sources. The article likewise reviews the principles of large HPPs operations allowing their classification as renewables, and Tajikistan’s hydropower potential substantiating the country’s natural intention to expand its hydropower. The research findings include the recommendation to allocate all types of financial support, currently available for developing renewable (alternative) energies, to advance large-scale hydropower generation.

Download the Paper

Available in Russian

To cite the paper: SultonovaT.I. & Ulugov U.A. (2022). Pravovye i ekologicheskie predposylki otneseniya krupnyh GES k vozobnovlyaemym istochnikam energii v usloviyah Tadzhikistana: iniciirovanie diskussii [Legal and environmental prerequisites for classifying large HPPs as renewable energy sources in Tajikistan: initiating the discussion]. Central Asian Journal of Sustainability and Climate Research. https://doi.org/10.29258/CAJSCR/2022/27-44.rus [In Russian]

Rerefences

Anisimov, A. P. (2010). Konstitutsionnyye osnovy prirodopol’zovaniya i okhrany okruzhayushchey sredy v Rossii: voprosy teorii [Constitutional bases of nature management and environmental protection in Russia: questions of theory]. Vlast’ zakona, 4, 22-32 [in Russian].

Atlas energeticheskikh resursov SSSR (1934) [Atlas of energy resources of the USSR]. NKTP USSR, Main Energy Directorate. Vol. 2, no. 16: Central Asian Republic. Moscow-Leningrad: State Energy Publishing House, 91 p [in Russian].

Garafova, D. I. (2018). Sokhraneniye klimata Zemli: mezhdunarodno-pravovoye regulirovaniye i osobennosti implementatsii v natsional’nom zakonodatel’stve otdel’nykh gosudarstv [Preservation of the Earth’s climate: international legal regulation and features of implementation in the national legislation of individual states]. Abstract of the dissertation of the candidate of legal sciences. Kazan’, 29 p [in Russian].

Gidroenergeticheskiye resursy Tadzhikistana (2022) [Hydropower resources of Tajikistan]. Website of the Ministry of Energy and Water Resources of the Republic of Tajikistan. https://www.mewr. tj/?page_id=614 [in Russian].

Ismailov, SH.M. (2009) Ekonomiko-pravovoye obespecheniye razvitiya energetiki v Tadzhikistane [Economic and legal support for energy development in Tajikistan]. Energeticheskoye pravo, 2, 25 – 30 [in Russian].

Kayumov, N.K. (2009). Energeticheskaya bezopasnost’ Tadzhikistana v usloviyakh novykh vyzovov i ugroz [Energy security of Tajikistan in the face of new challenges and threats]. Energeticheskoye pravo, 2, 11 – 16 [in Russian].

Konferentsiya OON po novym i vozobnovlyayemym istochnikam energii (1978) [UN Conference on New and Renewable Energy Sources]. A/RES/33/148. https://www.un.org/ru/ga/33/docs/33res.shtml [in Russian]

Kopylov, A.Ye. (2015). Sostoyaniye i perspektivy razvitiya zakonodatel’noy i normativnoy bazy rossiyskoy sistemy podderzhki VIE [The state and prospects for the development of the legislative and regulatory framework of the Russian system of support for renewable energy]. Energeticheskoye pravo – Izdatel’stvo Yurist, 2 (25), 39-44 [in Russian].

Lukutin, B.V. (2008). Vozobnovlyayemyye istochniki energii [Renewable energy sources. Tomsk]. Tomsk: Izdatel’stvo Tomskogo politekhnicheskogo universitetata, 187 p [in Russian].

O podderzhke ispol’zovaniya vozobnovlyayemykh istochnikov energii [About the supporting the use of renewable energy sources]. Zakon Respubliki Kazakhstan ot 4 iyulya 2009 goda, No 165-IV. https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/Z090000165_ [in Russian].

O Programme osvoyeniya vozobnovlyayemykh istochnikov energii i stroitel’stva malykh gidroelektrostantsiy na 2016-2020 [About the Program for the development of renewable energy sources and the construction of small hydropower plants for 2016-2020]. Postanovleniye Pravitel’stva Respubliki Tadzhikistan ot 30 dekabrya 2015 goda, No 795. http://adlia.tj/show_ doc.fwx?Rgn=126043 [in Russian].

Ob elektroenergetike [About of electric power industry]. Federal’nyy zakon ot 26.03.2003 No 35-FZ. http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_41502/ [in Russian].

Ob energetike [About of Energy]. Zakon Respubliki Tadzhikistan ot 29 noyabrya 2000 goda, No 33 – Akhbori Madzhlisi Oli Respubliki Tadzhikistan, 2000 god, No 11, st.504; 2005 god, No 12, st.633; 2007 god, No 6, st.436; No 7, st. 672; 2009 god, No 9-10, st.549; 2011 god. No 6, st. 440; 2013 god, No 7, st.,526; ZRT ot 28.12.13g., No 1054. [Informatsionnyy byulleten’] [in Russian].

Ob energosberezhenii i energoeffektivnosti [On energy saving and energy efficiency]. Zakon Respubliki Tadzhikistan ot 19 sentyabrya 2013 goda, No 1018 – Akhbori Madzhlisi Oli Respubliki Tadzhikistan, 2013 g., No 8–9, st. 651 [Informatsionnyy byulleten’] [in Russian].

Ob ispol’zovanii vozobnovlyayemykh istochnikov energii [About use of renewable energy sources: Law of the Republic of Tajikistan]. Zakon Respubliki Tadzhikistan ot 12 yanvarya 2010 goda, No 587 – Akhbori Madzhlisi Oli Respubliki Tadzhikistan, 2010 g., No 1, st. 11; Zakon RT ot 23.11.2015 g., No 1254. [Informatsionnyy byulleten’] [in Russian].

Popondopulo, V.F., Gorodov, O.A., Petrov, D.A. (2011). Vozobnovlyayemyye istochniki energii v elektroenergetike [Renewable energy sources in the electric power industry]. Energeticheskoye pravo – Izdatel’stvo Yurist, 1, 23-29 [in Russian].

Renewable Vs. (2018). Nonrenewable Energy Resources. https://sciencing.com/renewable-vs-nonrenewable-energy-resources-12071170.html

Vasil’yev, YU.S., Bezrukikh, P.P., Yelistratov, V.V., Sidorenko, G.I. (2009). Otsenki resursov vozobnovlyayemykh istochnikov energii v Rossii [Estimates of Renewable Energy Resources in Russia]. Sankt-Peterburg, 250 p [in Russian].

World Energy Outlook (2018). Sciencing URL: https://sciencing.com/renewable-vs-nonrenewable-energy-resources-12071170.html

Zillman, Donald N., Catherine Redgewell, Yinka O. Omorogbe, Lila K. Barrera-Hernandez (2008). Beyond the Carbon Economy. Energy Law in Transition. Oxford University Press, 26-37.